RecipeShare Test Kitchen

A cool mint ice cream with soft butter-mint character and a creamy base that keeps the flavor smooth rather than sharp.
This is a mint flavor built for softness rather than intensity. Instead of reading like a cold toothpaste-style peppermint scoop, it aims for a gentler butter-mint profile with a rounded finish.
White chocolate or buttery elements can help support that profile by giving the mint something richer to sit against. That keeps the flavor more confection-like than medicinal.
Mint flavors usually benefit from restraint because freezing amplifies sharp edges. The best result is cool and aromatic, not aggressively cold.
Serve it with chocolate cookies, on holiday dessert trays, or as a small palate-cleansing scoop after richer meals. It works best in modest portions where its delicate style can come through.
This flavor works because the mint is cushioned by richer ingredients rather than pushed to the front on its own. White chocolate and the creamier base give the peppermint something soft to sit against, which helps the scoop feel more like a confection than a sharp mint candy.
Freezing can exaggerate strong mint notes, so restraint matters more here than with many fruit flavors. A lighter hand gives a more elegant finish and keeps the ice cream from drifting into medicinal territory.
The base should stay smooth and rounded, with the mint reading as cool and clean rather than icy. Chilling fully before churning helps preserve that softer texture.
Because it is quite distinctive, smaller scoops usually make the best serving.
A cool mint ice cream with soft butter-mint character and a creamy base that keeps the flavor smooth rather than sharp.

Use pure peppermint extract for the cleanest flavor.
Add a swirl of white chocolate ganache for extra indulgence.
Serve with crushed buttermints on top for added crunch.
We use affiliate links, which may earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you.
In a small bowl, whisk 2 tbsp milk with cornstarch to make a slurry.
In another bowl, whisk softened cream cheese and salt until smooth.
In a saucepan, combine remaining milk, cream, sugar, corn syrup, and melted butter.
Bring to a rolling boil for 4 minutes.
Remove from heat, whisk in cornstarch slurry, return to boil for 1 minute until thickened.
Slowly whisk hot mixture into cream cheese until smooth.
Stir in white chocolate until fully melted, then add peppermint extract.
Chill mixture quickly in an ice bath for 30 minutes.
Pour into ice cream maker and churn until thick and creamy.
Transfer to a container, press parchment against surface, and freeze at least 4 hours before scooping.
9/9/2025
The peppermint is refreshing without being overpowering. So unique!
7/28/2025
The buttery richness with the cool peppermint is a perfect combo. Loved the smooth finish.
6/20/2025
Creamy and refreshing—this reminded me of old-fashioned buttermints at weddings!
Create and edit your own recipes, import from most websites, plan your week, and build smart grocery lists.
Import recipes from most websites
Create and edit your own recipes
Plan your week with the Meal Planner
Mark favourites for quick access
Build grocery lists from your meal plan
Tick off pantry items you already have
Serving Size: 1/2 cup (about 100 g)
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Add your personal creations and build your own recipe collection.